17 October 2011
London
Reporter: Anna Reitman
Securities Lending default image
UK collateral upgrade trade eyed by FSA
The Financial Services Authority (FSA) is considering enacting guidelines on the collateral upgrade trade after increasing activity has caused concerns over macroprudential risk.

A recent FT article claimed that sources within the financial services industry reported blocked “liquidity swap” transactions – which may include stock (securities) lending, repo transactions or sale plus total return swap - however, an FSA spokesman denied being aware of any blocked transactions since actions on guidance are still being put in place and the UK regulator continues to consult the industry on proposals, at the same time it is the FSA’s practice to not comment on supervisory actions with firms.

In stock lending, gilts, or UK government bonds, are lent by an insurer for a significant period in return for a fee and collateral. Legal ownership of the gilt passes to the borrowing bank counterparty - in the event of the bank counterparty defaulting, the insurer has recourse to the collateral.

“If structured and operated correctly, valuation, margining and over-collateralisation should protect the insurer against loss in the event of a ‘fire-sale’ of the collateral. To the extent there is insufficient collateral the insurer will have an unsecured claim against the bank counterparty,” the FSA writes in its guidance consultation.

The main areas of concern for the FSA are in the mechanics of risk management within organisations participating in liquidity transformation – seemingly trading up asset-backed securities (ABS) as this structured product is mentioned in the guidance consultation - and what the potential impact might be on the wider economy if the practice becomes more common.

This is quite likely to become a reality, as most industry experts across the banking, insurance and pension fund industries are expecting the collateral upgrade trade to become a major driver of securities lending activity since global regulations pushing OTC transactions on exchange will substantially increase the demand for high quality collateral to post to a CCP against derivatives trades.

Irving Henry, director of Prudential Capital and Risk at the British Bankers’ Association (BBA), says that the FSA proposals are in their infancy but that the regulator needs to spend more time looking at a wider variety of transactions and become more comfortable with the way that different market participants approach the practice.

“There was very much a feeling [during the consultation] that insurance companies need to be protected from banks and whether the governance of risk at the insurance companies was up to scratch,” he says. “But [insurance companies] felt better able to hang on to these types of [riskier] assets because they tend to be long investors and they are trying to get some additional yield which they are not able to do holding a shedload of gilts.”

Gilts fit better with banks which need the immediate liquidity, while insurance companies feel able to sit out stresses by holding onto the assets for a longer period of time, he adds.

Another sticking point for the FSA for liquidity swaps was on the issue of intragroup transactions, meaning that the insurance company and bank are part of the same Group. Henry explains that currently, those transactions are subject to regulatory scrutiny to ensure risks are captured properly but also tax authorities and auditors require transactions are done on an arms length and transparent basis.

Meanwhile, disclosures on stock lending in mutual funds is also a reported activity, something commonly understood by mutual fund trustees.

“There is something to be said about treating customers fairly and that the churning of a portfolio ought to be disclosed more widely than it is and there ought to be a better spread of the fees earned from such transactions because they accrue to the manager rather than to the investors,” Henry says. “But it would have been helpful if the FSA could have spent a bit more time talking to participants and given us some clear conclusions based on a pool of transactions…so we can start thinking about how this plays into financial stability.”

Apart from banks feeling pressured by Basel III and the capital requirement directive CRD IV, the insurance fund industry is facing regulations under Solvency II, which could make these transactions "uneconomic" according to the FSA.

“These rules are being developed in isolation and that silo [mentality] leads to issues not being addressed, because they fall through the gaps, but also unintended consequences,” Henry says, adding that if banks cannot swap riskier pools of assets with pension funds and insurance companies, it is not clear where those assets will go to relieve pressure on balance sheets.

More news
The latest news from Securities Lending Times
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
Stock loan falls short for buy side as liquidity source
25 July 2017 | London | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
Securities lending was voted the least popular source of liquidity in a survey of European buy-side heads of operations
Hedge fund H1 gains best since 2009
25 July 2017 | London | Reporter: Drew Nicol
The hedge fund industry has recorded one of its strongest H1 performance periods since the financial crisis, according to data and intelligence provider Preqin
Calypso gains stake in Sernova Financial
25 July 2017 | London | Reporter: Drew Nicol
Sernova Financial, which already leverages the Calypso Cloud platform, recreates the shared infrastructure and service items of clearing brokers
RMA keynote The Mooch heads to the West Wing
24 July 2017 | Naples | Reporter: Drew Nicol
Anthony Scaramucci, who appeared as keynote speaker at last year’s RMA securities lending conference in Florida, has been appointed as the White House communications director
Northern Trust’s Q2 lending revenue stutters
24 July 2017 | New York | Reporter: Drew Nicol
Northern Trust saw its securities lending earnings fall to $24.6 million in Q2
New recruits for BNY Mellon's alternative investment team
21 July 2017 | New York | Reporter: Drew Nicol
BNY Mellon has made two senior appointments to its alternative investment services team
Euroclear achieves record-breaking H1 collateral volume
21 July 2017 | Frankfurt | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
Post-trade service provider Euroclear saw achieved "record levels" of collateral outstanding through its Collateral Highway in the first half of 2017