19 April 2017
Reporter: Drew Nicol

Failed Icelandic bank loses collateral valuation dispute

The UK High Court ruled that the non-defaulting party, Raiffeisen Zentralbank Österreich, had the right to determine the fair market value of the collateral at dispute

Defunct Icelandic bank Landsbanki Islands has lost a legal challenge disputing the method used to value collateral that funded its securities lending and repo transactions around the time of its defaulted in 2008.

The UK High Court ruled in late March that the non-defaulting party, in this case Raiffeisen Zentralbank Österreich (RZB), had the right to determine the fair market value of the collateral at dispute.

When Iceland’s government seized control of Landsbanki, then the second largest bank in the country, in October 2008, it was engaged in 11 repo trades and three securities lending trades with Austrian banking group RZB.

The dispute related to the interpretation of the term ‘fair market value’ as stated in the 2000 editions of the global master securities lending agreement (GMSLA) and the global master repo agreement (GMRA)

RZB argued before the UK High Court that the overall collateral bucket, which included corporate bonds from Wells Fargo, Countrywide and Morgan Stanley, was worth €74.7 million.

This figure was contested by Landsbanki, which argued that the hyper-stressed market conditions of the time made a determination of fair market value difficult.

Issue was also raised regarding whether default notices were effectively served by RZB on 8 October 2008, a day after Landsbanki admitted it was unable to facilitate a margin call.

In ruling on the case, Justice Robin Knowles dismissed Landsbanki’s interpretation of the GMSLA and GMRA collateral rules and concluded that despite correct pricing under such conditions being difficult, the non-defaulting party had the right to do so.

Justice Knowles explained: “I am unable to treat as irrational an assessment of fair market value based on the information RZB did have in the present case and without more. I do not rule out that the position may be different in the circumstances of other cases.”

“There is no doubt that the information available in the present case was imperfect, and it is to be noted that it includes the Bloomberg or BGN prices ," Justice Knowles continued.

"However, the circumstances at that time were imperfect. Any assessment of fair market value would have been imperfect but the non-defaulting party was nonetheless entitled to make one.”

Justice Knowles also ruled that although Landsbanki was unable to produce proof of receipt of default notices and the onus for proving that such a notice was sent is on the sender, “it is more likely than not that the faxes were collected”.

More news
The latest news from Securities Lending Times
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
No further SFT regulations on the horizon, says European Commission
20 October 2017 | Paris | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
article synopsis 300 characters only so it fits to three lines. always add three periods to finish synopsis...
LEI compliance is non-negotiable, says ESMA
20 October 2017 | Paris | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
Steven Maijoor, chair of ESMA stated that there is no room for negotiation where legal entity identifiers are concerned
US appeals court dismisses US equity lending mismanagement case
20 October 2017 | Missouri | Reporter: Drew Nicol
Allegations of mismanagement of a securities lending programme brought by two US Bank pension beneficiaries was dismissed by the US Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit this week
Clearstream promises post-Brexit services continuity
19 October 2017 | London | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
Clearstream confirmed it will continue to offer stable custody services to its UK-based clients no matter how the Brexit negotiations evolve
EU commission lays down the law on MiFID II compliance
19 October 2017 | Brussels | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
Belgium, Malta, France, Greece, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Portugal, Spain and Sweden are among the 19 infringing member states due to face the commission’s wrath
Margin rules depress derivative contract terms, survey finds
19 October 2017 | Brussels | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
Only few changes were reported regarding credit terms and conditions with respect to non-centrally cleared OTC derivatives
AAOI and Euronav top FIS hot stocks lists
18 October 2017 | London | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
The Belgium-based operator of crude oil tankers and storage facilities, has been a regular feature on the list in the last month