03 November 2017
Washington DC
Reporter: Jenna Lomax

CCP may be more vulnerable to failure than we thought, OFR report shows


Central counterparties (CCP) could be more vulnerable to failure than conventional stress tests have shown, according to a new report by the Office of Financial Research (OFR).

Conventional stress tests usually estimate the ability of a CCP to withstand non-payment by its two largest counterparties, but, the report indicated that the safeguarding via beneficial DTCC data and the ‘Cover 2’ standard, draw a “different conclusion when [they] take into account network contagion”.

In the report entitled ‘How safe are central counterparties in Derivatives Markets?’, economists and researchers, Mark Paddrik and Hobart Peyton Young, explained that the introduction of the network contagion model in a stress test highlights new vulnerability to central clearing models.

Paddrick and Young further indicate how the network contagion model coupled with the Cover 2 standard, increases the likelihood of a CCP defaulting during a stress test of similar magnitude to the Federal Reserve’s 2015 Comprehensive Capital Analysis and Review (CCAR) shock.

This shock was “specifically designed to subject the financial markets to a severe but plausible market stress”.

Such a shock triggers a sudden drop in the value of credit instruments, which translates into large and sudden VM payments on CDS contracts.

The report stated: “When we take account of these network spillover effects, we find that the CCP for this market is potentially more vulnerable to default than conventional stress tests would suggest.”

Paddrick and Young suggest their advantage in their investigation is mainly due to their “use of credit default swap data to estimate the direct and indirect impacts of a default by CCP counterparties in derivatives trades.”

The contagion model changes the game by tracing how payment delinquencies by some firms can increase as they travel through the network of credit default swap (CDS) exposures.

The report states that the “Cover 2 standard is typically applied to a scenario where the two defaulting members are assumed to be those with the largest net variation margin (VM) obligations to the CCP”.

“A novel feature of this model is the treatment of stress transmission, which depends on firms’ liquidity buffers and their risk management policies. We demonstrate the sensitivity of the model to different values for the shock and stress transmission parameters.”

“The model allows us to estimate the probability of a CCP failure relative to the probability of a member’s failure while making minimal assumptions about the degree of correlation among member failure rates.”

More news
The latest news from Securities Lending Times
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
EXCLUSIVE: Sunil Daswani leaves Northern Trust
21 February 2018 | London | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
Sunil Daswani, head of international securities lending at Northern Trust has left the company
Top of hot stocks: TechnipFMC PLC and Match
21 February 2018 | London | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
TechnipFMC PLC, formed by the merger of oil services companies, led the FIS Astec Analytics hot stocks list for EMEA last week
ISLA responds to BMF’s draft circular
20 February 2018 | London | Reporter: Brian Bollen
The International Securities Lending Association (ISLA) has sent a letter to the German Ministry of Finance responding to the BMF’s draft circular released on 25 January 2018 on the subject of a manufactured dividend rule
SBL Network welcomes independent consultant
20 February 2018 | London | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
SBL Network Limited has appointed Charlotte Clout as an independent consultant
Fidessa sees revenue growth across all regions in 2017
20 February 2018 | London | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
Fidessa has reported that its yearly revenue increased by 7 percent for 2017, ending the year with £353.9 million compared to £331.9 million in 2016
Foreign investment in US down
19 February 2018 | Washington DC | Reporter: Brian Bollen
Official figures, released 15 February, by the US Department of the Treasury show a drop in foreign investment in the US in December
Minium, IBM and Promontory release joint white paper
19 February 2018 | London | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
The patchwork of outdated systems most firms use today is not fit for purpose, according to a white paper jointly released by Minium, IBM and Promontory