07 February 2018
Cape Town
Reporter: Brian Bollen

Short seller targets ‘loan shark’ Capitec


US research firm and short seller Viceroy Research has released a report to explain why “loan shark” Capitec should be placed into curatorship by the South African Reserve Bank (SARB).

The 33-page report explained that, based on its research and due diligence, Capitec is a loan shark with “massively understated defaults masquerading as a community microfinance provider”.

Viceroy has in turn been accused by Capitec of conducting a smear campaign in order to profit from extensive short selling of the South African lender.

It stated: “Capitec Bank Holdings Limited is a South Africa-focused microfinance provider to a majority low-income demographic, yet they out-earn all major commercial banks globally including competing high-risk lenders. We don’t buy this story.”

“Viceroy believes this is indicative of predatory finance which we have corroborated with substantial on-the-ground discussions with Capitec ex-employees, former customers, and individuals familiar with the business.

‘Viceroy’s extensive due diligence and compiled evidence suggests that indicates [sic] Capitec must take significant impairments to its loans which will likely result in a net-liability position. We believe Capitec’s concealed problems largely resemble those seen at African Bank Investments prior to its collapse in 2014.”

“We think that it’s only a matter of time before Capitec’s financials and business unravel, with macro headwinds creating an exponential risk of default and bankruptcy.”

Viceroy explained that the report provides underlying information and analysis that it believes supports the following conclusions.

Reconciliation of loan book values, maturity profiles and cash outflows imply Capitec is either fabricating new loans and collections, or refinancing ZAR 2.5 billion to 3 billion (USD 200 million to USD 240 million) in principal per year by issuing new loans to defaulting clients.

Viceroy suggested that the legal documents it has obtained show Capitec advising and approving loans to delinquent customers in order to repay existing loans. It said that these documents also show Capitec engaging in reckless lending practices as defined by South Africa’s National Credit Act. Viceroy stated that this corroborates its loan book analysis.

According to Viceroy, Capitec’s loan book is massively overstated as a consequence of refinancing delinquent loans and that analysis against competitors suggested an impairment/write-off impact of ZAR 11 billion (USD 921 million) will more accurately represent the delinquencies and risk in Capitec’s portfolio.

Viceroy said: “Legal experts that we have spoken to believe that the outcome of an upcoming reckless and predatory lending test case in March 2018 will be used to trigger a multi-party litigation refund (class action). We believe that, at a minimum, Capitec will be required to refund predatory origination fees primarily related to multi-loan facilities; an estimated ZAR 12.7 billion (USD 1 billion).”

In a published rebuttal to Viceroy’s claims, Capitec stated: “We believe that the campaign will continue for the foreseeable future. Shareholders can expect the release of fresh attacks and false allegations over an extended period. Capitec consequently advises shareholders to use caution when reacting to such allegations.”

It added: “Only 7.3 percent of Capitec’s credit clients currently qualify for loans in excess of 60 months (3.6 percent qualify for 84-month loans). The scoring models for the 61 to 84-month loans currently target 12-month default rates of 4.2 percent in aggregate (2 percent for 84-month loans). The portfolios are naturally weighted to the larger amounts and consequently the longer-term and lower risk clients.”

The Republic of South Africa’s National Treasury also weighed in describing Viceroy’s actions as “reckless”.

According to the National Treasury, the way in which Viceroy released its report is “clear proof that it is not acting in the public interest nor in the interest of financial stability in South Africa”.

The statement said: “Whilst the Treasury expects prudential and market conduct regulators in SA to consider all relevant reports in the public domain, and to act where any risks or transgressions in the law are identified, Treasury is of the view that the Viceroy report provides no basis to put any bank under curatorship.”

It continued: “The National Treasury has been in constant contact with the Registrar of Banks since the report was released, and is satisfied with the assurance from the SARB that Capitec is well capitalised, liquid and solvent, and meets all prudential requirements. This means that the funds of depositors are safe.”

The National Treasury has requested that the financial services board considers whether it should initiate a market abuse investigation into the conduct of Viceroy.

More news
The latest news from Securities Lending Times
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
BoE release consultation on a new rule for central counterparties
16 February 2018 | London | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
BoE states that this proposed rule of written notice would “support the UK Government’s approach to the implementation of the EU Network and Information Systems Directive”
ASX sees 5.8 percent increase in collateral management activity
16 February 2018 | Sydney | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
The increase in the use of derivatives and OTC was due to a rise in futures trading, OTC clearing and collateral management activity
SBL Network bolsters its P2P securities lending team
16 February 2018 | London | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
SBL Network Limited has hired Charlotte Clout, reporting to Tammy Phillips, CEO at SBL
Citi’s agency lending sales chief departs
16 February 2018 | New York | Reporter: Drew Nicol
Citi’s Americas head of sales for it’s agency securities lending, collateral management, and separate account cash management businesses, Jeff Bonaldi, has left to pursue a number of entrepreneurial ventures
SIFMA testifies on legislative proposals regarding derivatives
15 February 2018 | Washington DC | Reporter: Brian Bollen
SIFMA has testified to the US House of Representatives Committee on Financial Services Subcommittee on areas that could make regulations more risk-sensitive, less complex and clearer
More than 35 percent of investors asked are planning to add to their European exposure in 2018
ECB rings collateral changes
14 February 2018 | Frankfurt | Reporter: Brian Bollen
The European Central Bank has issued a series of amendments relating to the Eurosystem’s monetary policy implementation