22 February 2017
London
Reporter: Drew Nicol

OFR: Margin requirements must rise to avoid amplifying market shocks


Market regulators must raise margin requirements for over-the-counter derivative transactions in order to address their procyclical nature and avoid amplifying liquidity issues during stress scenarios, according to the US Office of Financial Research (OFR).

In a recent research paper, the OFR examined the problem of setting margin levels that are high enough to reduce credit exposure yet stable enough to mitigate unintended procyclicality.

“The growing use of margin requirements in over-the-counter derivative transactions reduces counterparty credit risk but may amplify shocks to the financial system through margin calls when volatility spikes,” explained Paul Glasserman and Qi Wu, the paper’s authors.

“In times of higher market volatility, price changes are larger, so the minimum level of margin required to cover potential price changes with high confidence must also be larger.”

“This dynamic can, however, have a destabilising effect on financial markets. With risk-sensitive margin requirements, a spike in volatility leads to margin calls on the firms trading through a CCP or bilaterally.”

“The increase in volatility is likely to be correlated with other indicators of market stress, in which case these firms would need to post additional collateral precisely when it becomes most difficult to raise cash or other liquid assets.”

The paper proposes shifting to ‘through the cycle’ margin levels that are less sensitive to day-to-day market conditions and therefore less prone to spike at the onset of market stress.

“The cost of this added stability is that margin levels need to be higher in quiet times and may seem unnecessarily high as memories of past volatility fade,” the authors added.

The paper also raises questions over the competence of the current EU rules regarding requirements of central counterparties adopt at least one of three suggested methods to minimise procyclicality.

“These rules are vague and therefore open to interpretation, despite the specificity suggested by the numerical values associated with the three options. The rules also fail to differentiate between features of different asset classes.”

More regulation news
The latest news from Securities Lending Times
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
Margin rules depress derivative contract terms, survey finds
19 October 2017 | Brussels | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
Respondents to the commission’s quarterly survey on EU securities financing market liquidity cited the implementation of European Market Infrastructure Regulation (EMIR) margin requirements for non-cleared OTC derivative contracts as the main driv
Trax gains MiFID II ARM licence from UK FCA
29 September 2017 | London | Reporter: Drew Nicol
Reporting solution provider Trax is among the first to be approved by the UK FCA as an approved reporting mechanism (ARM) for transaction reporting services under MiFID II
Shadow banking will not be banned, confirms IMF
26 September 2017 | Helsinki | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
The IMF, along with the FSB and other regulatory bodies, have no desire to shut down the alternative financing industry but that some aspects of the market’s risk features must be managed
AcadiaSoft expands user base for IM compliance
21 September 2017 | Massachusetts | Reporter: Drew Nicol
The second phase of the IM rules went live on 1 September under the regulatory framework of BCBS and IOSCO
FCA takes pragmatic approach to MiFID II deadline
20 September 2017 | London | Reporter: Drew Nicol
The UK’s financial conduct authority has indicated it will accept a soft roll out of the second Markets in Financial Instruments Directive in January
Ten-year T2S saga comes to an end
19 Septemeber 2017 | Brussels | Reporter: Stephanie Palmer
The Target2-Securities pan-European harmonised settlement platform is finally fully operational, as the Spanish and Baltic markets completed their migration yesterday
Margin rules changing collateral industry, says ISDA
19 September 2017 | London | Reporter: Drew Nicol
New margining rules for non-cleared derivatives are significantly changing collateral practices, according to the International Swaps and Derivatives Association